Always Emily Read online

  Also by Michaela MacColl

  Nobody’s Secret

  Promise the Night

  Prisoners in the Palace

  For Margaux. Always challenging.

  Always worth it. I love you. —Mom

  Copyright © 2014 by Michaela MacColl.

  All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher.

  ISBN: 978-1-4521-3746-9

  The Library of Congress has previously cataloged this under: ISBN 978-1-4521-1174-2

  Design by Kate Cunningham and Sara Gillingham Studio. Typeset in Hoefler Text, Copperplate, and Shelley Allegro.

  Chronicle Books LLC

  680 Second Street

  San Francisco, CA 94107

  Chronicle Books—we see things differently. Become part of our community at www.chroniclebooks.com/teen.

  I got the sexton, who was digging Linton’s grave, to

  remove the earth off her coffin lid, and I opened it.

  I thought, once, I would have stayed there: when I

  saw her face again–it is hers yet!

  May 1825

  The minister pronounced the final benediction for Elizabeth Brontë, aged ten. The funeral was finally over.

  The surviving Brontës huddled in the family pew. Charlotte, the eldest child at nine, sat stiffly, her back perfectly straight. She frowned at her younger sister, Emily, who had fidgeted unconscionably during the long service. Then she clutched her eight-year-old brother Branwell’s hand. With a loud sniff, he snatched it away and wiped his nose with his knuckles.

  The sexton led the Reverend Brontë and the children to a wide gravestone embedded in the church floor. Their mother and other sister, Marie, were buried beneath it and now Elizabeth would join them.

  As the Elizabeth-size coffin was brought down from the altar, a sob escaped from Charlotte. Emily stood off to one side, her chin up despite the tears rolling down her cheeks. Branwell blew his nose hard and pressed his body against his father’s side.

  The sexton, an old family friend, levered up the stone slab, exposing a crypt beneath the floor. When he placed a ladder inside the crypt, a heavy, foul dust floated up and obscured their vision. Charlotte and Branwell gagged.

  Emily stepped forward, her color high and her eyes shining. “I see her,” she whispered. “The shape of dear Elizabeth.” Holding her hands out, she stepped to the edge of the crypt.

  “Emily!” Charlotte yanked her back from the precipice.

  “Don’t fall in,” Branwell cried. “Then I’ll have hardly any sisters at all.”

  The sexton climbed inside the crypt. His assistant easily handed down the tiny coffin as though it were no weight at all.

  “Thank you, John,” Rev. Brontë said in a heavy voice when the sexton rejoined them.

  “My sympathies, reverend.” He nodded to the children and added, “Do you have any other tasks for me before I close up the crypt?”

  “Yes,” Rev. Brontë said, drawing him to the vestry.

  The children were left alone. Branwell moved a safe distance away from the opening to stand with his back to a stone column. His complexion had a greenish hue. Charlotte was about to join him when Emily broke the silence.

  “Mr. Brown is going to seal up the grave?”

  Branwell frowned. “Well, he won’t leave a big open hole in the floor.”

  “But how will Elizabeth ascend if she’s locked in that hole?”

  “A person’s spirit can ascend through anything,” Charlotte declared.

  “Through stone? Are you certain?” Emily persisted. “Have you ever seen a soul go to heaven?”

  “No one can see it, Emily,” Charlotte said. “The ascension is invisible.”

  “In paintings we see the angel flying upward,” Emily retorted. She might be only seven years old, but she was confident her logic was irrefutable.

  “Don’t be stupid, Emily.” Branwell finally roused himself from his misery. “That’s just in art. Not life.”

  “How do you know?” Emily shot back. “Just because you and Charlotte are older than me doesn’t mean you know everything. What if Elizabeth can’t escape unless the crypt is open?”

  “Don’t be morbid, Emily,” Charlotte scolded. “The crypt won’t be opened until another one of us dies.”

  “Exactly! So let’s release her now.” Emily placed her foot on the topmost rung of the ladder.

  “Don’t do it, Emily!” cried Branwell.

  Charlotte balked, glancing sharply between their father speaking in hushed tones with his sexton and her sister descending into the crypt.

  “Come on, Charlotte,” Emily said. “Don’t you want to know what it’s like down there?”

  Charlotte hesitated, then snatched a candle from the altar and followed Emily down to the narrow space. It was damp and smelt of decay. Built-in stone alcoves held the coffins on either side of her. Elizabeth’s coffin was on a bottom shelf.

  “There aren’t any latches,” Emily whispered, running the tips of her fingers across the side of the coffin.

  “There’s no need.”

  Emily reached toward Elizabeth’s coffin to lift open the lid.

  “Emily! You go too far!” Charlotte dropped the candle and grabbed Emily’s wrists so tightly that Emily cried out.

  “What harm can it do to look?” Emily pried Charlotte’s fingers away from her hand. “If I’m right, her soul can soar away. If I’m wrong, at least we can wish her a proper farewell.”

  Charlotte eyes shot back and forth between the coffin and her sister. Finally she said, “I’ll do it. You’re too little.”

  Emily stepped back. Charlotte lifted the lid, her mouth twisting to keep from gagging on the sickly smell. Aghast, she let the lid drop.

  “Open it, Charlotte! I want to see her dear countenance!” Emily’s face was distorted and grotesque in the flickering candlelight.

  “What if it isn’t our sister anymore?” Charlotte asked urgently. “What if she’s become something horrible?”

  The thought gave even Emily pause. After a silence, she said, “I don’t care!” She lunged toward the coffin and threw open the lid.

  The sisters stared at the still body of ten-year-old Elizabeth. Her face was sunken from the ravages of the graveyard cough that had killed her. Her pretty hair had been cut short at the boarding school by a headmaster who thought long hair encouraged vanity. Her skin was pale, like ivory.

  “She looks at peace,” Charlotte said, relieved.

  “She does, doesn’t she?” Emily said, staring intently at her dead sister’s face. She reached over and brushed a lock of hair from Elizabeth’s cold forehead. “Do you think we’ve released her soul?”

  Before Charlotte could answer, they were startled by a booming voice above their heads. “Charlotte! Get out of there now!” Their father peered down at them, holding Branwell’s hand. He was angrier than they had ever heard him before. “And you brought Emily with you? For shame!”

  Emily started to speak, but Charlotte put her fingers to her lips. It would do no good for both of them to be punished.

  Charlotte climbed out, followed by Emily. Standing in front of their father, they didn’t dare meet his eyes. After an excruciating moment, he said, “Charlotte, what were you thinking? You must be more responsible. Don’t you realize you’re the oldest now?” His voice trembled and tears ran down his cheeks.

  Charlotte put her hands to her face and sobbed.

  Emily put her arm around Charlotte’s shoulders. She couldn’t imagine anything more awful than being the responsible one.

  Many [girls], already smitten, went home

  only to die: some died at the school, and were

  buried quietly and quickly, the
nature of

  the malady forbidding delay.

  August 1835

  How much farther?” Emily asked. Her long body pressed into the corner of the carriage seat, as if she were trying to propel herself back home toward Haworth.

  “A mile less than the last time you asked,” Charlotte said between gritted teeth. She sat primly in the corner, her feet barely touching the floor. Charlotte tried to make up for her lack of inches with perfect posture. A notebook and pen were at hand, but Charlotte hadn’t written a single word. Emily had proved to be a distraction as a traveling companion.

  “You didn’t tell me this school was so far away,” Emily said, staring out the dirty window. “I never would have agreed to go.”

  “You didn’t agree,” Charlotte pointed out. “Father insisted.”

  “Because you badgered him without respite.”

  “Badger?” Charlotte’s hand went to her bodice. “I’m sorry if planning for the future is bothersome to you and Father.”

  Emily glared at her sister with raised eyebrows. Suddenly she tugged the window open and stuck her head out.

  “Em, close the window. Ladies don’t thrust their heads out into the road. It’s common.”

  “I don’t care what anyone thinks.” Emily shoved her body farther out the window. She recognized the landscape—they were near the great bog of Crow Hill. Charlotte had lied when she said they were making progress; they were barely ten miles from home. The landscape was still familiar. The great green hills were just starting to turn purple with the heather. In September, these hills would be heavy with the scent of the flowers and their vibrant color would swamp the eyes. But Emily wouldn’t be there to see it.

  On the horizon, beneath a row of fir trees stunted by the constant wind on the moors, Emily noticed a figure on horseback galloping across the top of a hill, the perfect symbol of the liberty she was giving up. Emily wanted to fix the memory of that rider in her mind. When she was locked up at school this anonymous figure would be her talisman; a promise that someday Emily would roam the moors again.

  Suddenly her shoulder was gripped by a small hand and Emily was hauled inside. Charlotte, stumbling against the motion of the carriage, slammed the window shut. “The moors will still be there when you get home.” She sat back down and crossed her arms.

  “But how long will that be?” Emily said. “When you went to school, you stayed for two entire years.”

  “I came home for holidays.” She patted Emily’s leg. “And you will, too. You’ll be home for Christmas.”

  “Four months!” Emily’s voice was high and anxious. “How will I stand it?”

  “I’ve told you time and time again—school is not a punishment. Father is a fine teacher, but at Roe Head School I learned things I never could have at the parsonage.”

  Emily’s expression spoke eloquently of her doubts.

  “Don’t scowl at me like that, Emily. I’ve learned languages and geography and grammar. Your education has been too eccentric. If you’re to earn a living, you must know the academic subjects as well as music, deportment, and the rest.” Charlotte’s words slipped glibly off her tongue from long repetition.

  “I don’t care about earning my living,” Emily exclaimed. “No one wants me to work except you!”

  “Look at me, Emily,” Charlotte commanded. When Emily continued to stare out the window, Charlotte reached over and grabbed her sister’s chin. “You’re seventeen now, and we must face the facts of our situation. Father is our only bulwark against destitution. When he dies, we lose our income and our home. We must be prepared to support ourselves.”

  Emily batted Charlotte’s hand away. “Your concern for the future keeps you imprisoned in the present. Why lock yourself up in a school when Father’s healthy as an ox? You worry for nothing.”

  Charlotte’s hand clenched and unclenched. “How can you forget his illness this past spring? We might have lost him then!” Her wide brown eyes filled with tears as she remembered those days nursing their father. It was then she’d formulated a plan to save the family. She would return to school, but as a teacher. Rather than a full salary, her recompense would include tuition for Emily. It was the perfect plan. Except for one thing. Emily.

  “I have no interest in teaching or governessing.” Emily spoke with deliberation. Charlotte had tried to arrange everything without consulting Emily, who would not soon forgive her sister for it.

  “Would you prefer marriage?” Charlotte asked. “Because that’s your only alternative.” A snort was Emily’s only response. Charlotte leaned back against the dusty cushion and closed her eyes. Melodrama was exhausting.

  After another mile or so, Emily spoke in a softer voice. “What is this school like? Will I hate it?”

  Charlotte opened her eyes and smiled. “You may like it very much. I made good friends there. You’ve met my friend Ellen. She’s lovely, don’t you agree?”

  Emily tugged at the fingers of her darned gloves, picking at the ragged seams. “I suppose so.”

  “The days are filled with learning,” Charlotte continued. “It’s very well organized.”

  Emily’s eyes filled with malice; she asked, “And how much writing did you do while you were there? Did the Adventures of Angria continue at Roe Head or did they shrivel wasted on the vine?”

  Charlotte was silent.

  “I seem to remember you writing frantically when you came home,” Emily said.

  “Miss Wooler, the headmistress, says we must bend our inclination to our duty. If necessary, I’ll sacrifice my writing to earn security for my family,” Charlotte muttered.

  “Selflessness is your specialty, not mine,” Emily retorted. “What if I am not willing to surrender my dreams?”

  Charlotte glared at Emily, who had the grace to look abashed.

  With her facility for logic that alternately impressed and infuriated Charlotte, Emily leapt to another argument. “If I have to go to school, why do I have to change the way I look?” Emily ran her fingers across her scalp and bits of crimped hair broke off in her hands. “Look what your hairdressing did! I look absurd with curls.”

  Charlotte privately agreed Emily’s fair coloring and light eyes were better suited to a less labored hairdressing, but she hastened to reassure her sister. “No, it’s fashionable.” She wrapped one of her dark ringlets around her finger. “I’m trying to spare you the mistakes I made. When I arrived at school, everyone made fun of my clothes and hair.”

  “What do I care about what people think?” Emily snapped her fingers with a loud snap, a habit Charlotte deplored because she couldn’t do it.

  “You’re not in Haworth anymore,” Charlotte said. “I’m trying to keep you from being lonely like I was at first.”

  Emily shot a glance at her sister. With an unfamiliar pang of guilt, she reached out and took Charlotte’s hand. “You’re trying to help me and I’m acting the shrew.” After a moment, she added, “I’m out of my element and it’s putting me out of sorts. Tell me more about the school so I know what to expect.”

  “The students take long walks, weather permitting. You’ll like that.”

  “Weather permitting? I walk in any weather. The more wuthering the better.” Stormy weather on the moors was called a wuthering and it was one of Emily’s favorite words.

  “We walk often enough,” Charlotte said firmly. “Miss Wooler says it builds strong bodies and spurs the appetite. The food is quite good—and unlike home, we don’t have to do the washing up.”

  Emily looked sidelong at Charlotte. “It’s not like . . . Cowan Bridge?” This was the question she had avoided asking ever since school had become inevitable. Two of their sisters had died at Cowan Bridge from cold and neglect.

  “Of course not!” Charlotte contemplated her sister with pity. No wonder Emily was so obstinate about school; how could she have not seen it? “Cowan Bridge was an awful place. Father would never make that mistake again.” Her voice contained a speck of blame for their father’s ca
relessness. “And I’ll be there with you. There’s nothing to fear.”

  “You and I will share a room, won’t we?” Emily asked.

  Charlotte had dreaded this question. “You hate sharing a room with me!”

  “But it would be a familiar irritation,” Emily said.

  “I’m to be a teacher, so I’ll have my own room,” Charlotte said, looking at Emily warily. “You’ll be in the dormitory.”

  Emily straightened up and glared at Charlotte. “I have to share a room with strangers?”

  Charlotte took a deep breath and delivered the worst news. “You’ll share a bed with another student.”

  Emily’s face was like stone.

  “But in the winter, it’s handy for the warmth,” Charlotte hurried on. “And it’s fun to have someone to whisper secrets with in the dark.”

  “My secrets are my own,” Emily said flatly.

  The carriage slowed and turned onto a gravel drive. Emily abandoned Charlotte and studied the school as the carriage crunched up the incline. The building was large—three stories—and surrounded by giant oak and cedar trees.

  “You didn’t say it was so big,” Emily whispered.

  “Truly, Emily, it’s a good school,” Charlotte answered. “You could be happy here. If only you’ll try.”

  The carriage shuddered to a stop. The driver hopped down from his perch atop the roof and opened the door. Charlotte, stiff from the ride, awkwardly climbed down. Emily jumped to the ground without using the step.

  Staring up at the imposing wooden doors, Emily muttered, “I won’t last a week.”

  “Nonsense,” Charlotte said, her cheerful tone ringing ominously false. “Give it a month. By then you will have settled in and you won’t want to be anywhere else.”

  As if they had a heft and weight, Emily pushed away her fears with a wave of her hand. “A month then, Charlotte.” But in the privacy of her mind, Emily added, “After then, with or without you, I’m going home.”